The Amityville Horror: The True Story Behind NY’s Most Haunted House
Uncover the chilling true story of the Amityville Horror house, from the DeFeo murders to the Lutz family’s paranormal claims. Explore facts, myths, and legacy.
The Amityville Horror is one of America’s most infamous haunted house tales, blending true crime, paranormal terror, and enduring controversy. Centered around a Dutch Colonial home at 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, New York, this story has inspired books, films, and debates about its authenticity. Dive into the dark history, eerie claims, and unanswered questions behind the legend.
A Brief History of the Amityville House
The Early Years
The Amityville house was originally built in the mid-19th century as a modest family home. For decades, it served as a quiet residence on the outskirts of Amityville, New York—until its dark chapter began to unfold.
The Origins: The DeFeo Murders and the House’s Dark Past
The Tragic Night of November 13, 1974
The Amityville Horror’s roots lie in a real-life tragedy. Ronald “Butch” DeFeo Jr. murdered six family members—his parents and four siblings—in their sleep. The killings shocked the quiet Long Island community, and DeFeo’s claim of hearing “voices” that drove him to violence became a key part of the haunting narrative.
The Lutz Family’s Move-In
Thirteen months later, George and Kathy Lutz purchased the house at a steep discount, aware of its grim history. They moved in with their three children on December 18, 1975, only to flee 28 days later, alleging relentless paranormal terror.
The Haunting: 28 Days of Terror
Paranormal Activity Claims
The Lutze’s reported horrifying experiences:
Unexplained cold spots and foul odors resembling rotting flesh.
Green slime oozing from walls and ghostly apparitions of a pig-like creature with glowing eyes.
Levitation, violent physical attacks, and Kathy’s transformation into an “old woman” overnight.
A hidden red room in the basement, discovered under the floorboards, which they believed was a portal for evil.
The “Demon” and the Priest’s Failed Blessing
A priest allegedly called to bless the house reported being told, “Get out!” by an unseen force. Holy water reportedly boiled, and the priest fell ill shortly after.
The Aftermath: Media Frenzy and Skepticism
The Amityville Horror Book and Films
In 1977, Jay Anson’s book The Amityville Horror became a bestseller, followed by a 1979 film starring James Brolin. The story captivated audiences but faced scrutiny. Critics pointed out inconsistencies, such as the Lutzes’ financial motives and lack of corroborating witnesses.
Hoax Allegations and Legal Battles
Ronald DeFeo’s lawyer, William Weber, later claimed the haunting was a hoax concocted with the Lutzes to profit from the story. Skeptics also noted the house’s lack of documented paranormal activity after the Lutzes left.
The Legacy: Why Amityville Still Haunts Pop Culture
Paranormal Investigations and Tours
Despite skepticism, 112 Ocean Avenue remains a magnet for ghost hunters. Current owners (since the 1990s) deny any hauntings, but tours and documentaries keep the legend alive.
Psychological vs. Supernatural Explanations
Experts suggest the Lutzes may have experienced mass hysteria or PTSD from living in a murder house. Others argue the story reflects societal fears of the occult in the 1970s.
Visiting the Amityville House Today
Can You Tour 112 Ocean Avenue?
The house, still a private residence, has undergone renovations to deter tourists. Its iconic quarter-moon windows were removed, but fans still visit the neighborhood.
Amityville Horror Museum and Merchandise
Nearby, the Amityville Historical Society offers insights into the case, while shops sell memorabilia like replica “Jody the Pig” dolls.
Conclusion: Fact, Fiction, or Something In Between?
The Amityville Horror remains a cultural enigma. Was it a genuine paranormal event, a hoax, or a blend of trauma and suggestion? Regardless, its impact on horror lore is undeniable. For skeptics and believers alike, 112 Ocean Avenue symbolizes humanity’s fascination with the unknown.
Explore More:
Book Recommendation: The Amityville Horror by Jay Anson
Related Topic: The Conjuring vs. Amityville: Hollywood’s Take on Haunted Houses
Plan Your Visit (Respectfully):
📍 112 Ocean Avenue, Amityville, NY 11701 (Note: The house is private property; observe from a distance.)
